There are not any defining traits about Animal Crossing Nook Miles Ticket him which warrent the improvement into Brawl. None. He's JUST another Swordfighter, which we do not require. I am not knowledgeable about the FE series, but gimme Hector, even in the event that you gotta have somebody. Or an INTERESTING swordfighter.
Could one of those Ike fans please point out to me exactly what makes Ike distinct? What makes Ike so unqiue he wants to be contained into what could possibly be the very best figthing game of all time?
That's your view, and you're entitled to it. Do not make the mistake of assuming it to be a rule for SSB, though. We have no sign that Sakurai is at all concerned about the weapons used by each individual persona -- and if anything else, the fact that novices are using swords in larger numbers this time (see Pit, Meta Knight, and Ike; and that's with hardly over half the anticipated roster revealed) is an indicator that he isn't very concerned about it. Super Smash Brothers is not Street Fighter -- theres no"unwritten rule" restricting weapons use to a minimal or providing fist-fighters a taste over weapon-wielders.
If anything, it may be argued that the prevalence of unarmed fighters are best balanced out by the inclusion of more weapon-users, swords or (that is not an argument I would make myself, but it might be produced out of much more merit than the debate that there are too many swords-users). Besides, the simple truth is that swords are the most common weapon given to video game heroes, because they're the archetypical epic weapon --'ve been because the Samurai of Japan and the myths of the knights of Europe. There is no good reason to punish characters such as that. The character's weapon or fighting style of choice is not a fantastic reason to restrict them out of SSB; its nothing but pure private bias.
You know, I get that nowadays we all understand Ike and Marth as having entirely different playstyles, but as a player who started out occasionally playing Brawl at my buddy's home, I had a whole lot of difficulty telling apart Marth from Ike. Together with Byleth, even casuals can tell them apart as a result of their powerful bow, lance, Warlock Punch-like down special, and alts, but as a total casual, the one thing I remembered about Ike and Marth from utilizing them in Subspace was that one of them felt more powerful and a bit more fun.
Even though Ike is not a Marth clone, I believe that it can be trying for total casuals who've only played with them to articulate what makes them different. I think Sakurai realized this, which is why he decided to proceed with Robin since the brand new FE rep for Smash 4 instead of Chrom and not one of those non-echo FE characters have relied entirely on sword moves since then.
The shift to elderly Ike in Smash4 additionally helped to distinguish him visually from Marth. I truly don't understand why they made young Ike the buy Animal Crossing Items default in Ultimate (though I like his youthful layout better).